For months, the climate world and the broader Democratic coalition have argued over whether the sweeping bipartisan permitting reform bill will be good or bad for the energy transition. But inside the Senate, which just passed the legislation by a 62–33 vote, concerns about tribal sovereignty overshadowed the debate over emissions — and now are likely to influence negotiations in the House, too.
While tribal nations have sovereignty over development within their reservation boundaries, any development on sacred sites and cultural resources beyond those boundaries is subject to a special review under the 1966 National Historic Preservation Act. That law requires federal agencies to consult with tribes, but not to win their consent.
Large-scale energy projects, including the 550-mile SunZia transmission line that carries wind power from New Mexico to Arizona and California, have previously drawn pushback from tribes despite the federal government engaging in these NHPA reviews. Some influential tribal organizations believe that the proposed changes to the NHPA under the permitting bill would infringe on their sovereignty — and water down the already imperfect government-to-government consultation process.
org.
Source link







