The people who speak most confidently in meetings aren’t always the people with the best ideas. Here’s how leaders can stop overlooking valuable talent.
Every workplace has someone who seems to have an answer for everything. They’re quick to contribute in meetings, comfortable challenging colleagues and rarely hesitate when an executive asks for an opinion.
Then there’s the employee who listens carefully, takes notes and says very little.
Which one gets noticed? Too often, it’s the person who speaks first.
I’ve led and worked with teams across consulting, technology and marketing, and I’ve learned to be careful about equating confidence with capability. People communicate differently. Some think through problems by talking. Others need time to consider the information before forming an opinion.
Neither approach automatically produces better judgment. But many workplaces reward one more visibly than the other.
Think about how most brainstorming sessions operate. A leader presents a problem and asks for ideas. Someone immediately offers a suggestion. Another person agrees, adds something, and the conversation moves forward.
Within minutes, a direction begins to emerge. The session appears productive. People are engaged, ideas are flowing, and decisions are being made.
If the first confident suggestion becomes the foundation for the discussion, everyone else may spend the meeting reacting to that idea instead of considering alternatives.
This is especially problematic when the most senior person speaks first. Employees may hesitate to challenge an executive, even when they recognize a weakness in the proposed approach.
That’s why I prefer giving people the problem to think about before asking them to solve it together.
Source link







