A university that subscribes to a research journal may give faculty access to its articles. Feeding years of those articles into an artificial intelligence (AI)-powered knowledge system raises a different question about what the subscription permits. Recent copyright rulings show why employers, universities, nonprofits and public agencies need to ask that question before putting AI to work, even when a vendor built and trained the model.
Complete the form to unlock this article and enjoy unlimited free access to all PYMNTS content — no additional logins required.
In a Thursday (Nov. 19) analysis of four copyright cases, Polsinelli attorneys argued that institutions need to know where their data came from, what rights came with it, what the system does with it and what it produces. For organizations accustomed to treating copyright as a publishing or licensing issue, AI brings those questions into routine decisions about procurement, research and operations.
In “Thomson Reuters v. ROSS Intelligence,” the Third Circuit rejected a fair-use defense for the use of Westlaw headnotes in developing an AI-powered legal research product. The court considered the commercial purpose and the fact that the resulting product competed with Westlaw. The case shows why the purpose of the new tool and its effect on the market for the original material matter.
Federal district courts in “ Bartz v. Anthropic ” and “ Kadrey v. Meta” found that using copyrighted books to train large language models qualified as fair use on the records before them. But the Bartz court treated Anthropic’s acquisition and retention of pirated copies for a general-purpose library as a separate issue .
Source link







