Jaguar Land Rover has won a significant round in its legal battle against BYD. The District Court of The Hague ruled on Friday that the Chinese automaker's Ti7 SUV infringes JLR's registered EU design for the Defender. The judge has therefore barred BYD from importing, producing, selling, or otherwise trading the vehicle anywhere in the European Union.
The Ti7 is a five- or seven-seat plug-in hybrid that BYD launched in China last year and is now preparing to bring to international markets. Anyone who has seen one will understand why the Tata Motors-owned company took issue with its appearance. The SUV has a boxy body, upright windows, a flat roofline, and a rear-mounted spare wheel. Those familiar ingredients give it a silhouette that looks remarkably close to the modern Defender.
But BYD's lawyers argued that the two vehicles have plenty of distinguishing features. They pointed to differences in the headlights, grille, bumper layout, hood, windows, and wheel arches. The court wasn't convinced, however, concluding that those details weren't enough to change the overall impression created by the two designs.
According to the ruling, the Defender's appearance is defined by several distinctive elements: its rounded shoulders and corners, the signature panel in the C-pillar, rounded wheel-arch cutouts, a continuous glasshouse, and the vehicle's overall silhouette. Taken together, the judge found that these characteristics give the Defender a recognizable design that the BYD Ti7 infringes.
The case centers on a registered EU design dating back to 2018, before the current-generation Defender made its public debut a year later.
Source link







